Black & White photography?

Michael · 11-30-2006, 01:36 PM

Does anyone know if there is a difference between the pictures coming from a camera that has the black and white setting on as compared to taking the picture, made in color, and desaturating it in photoshop?

Aren't the effects different? Meaning, aren't the black and white photos from the camera nicer?

Choleric · 11-30-2006, 11:59 PM

You have a lot more control if you convert it to B&W in photoshop, I also believe you should always shoot in colour in digital photography and then change it afterwords. Afterall it is a lot harder to add colour to a B&W photo than to take the colour away from a colour photo.

Michael · 12-01-2006, 06:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Choleric

You have a lot more control if you convert it to B&W in photoshop, I also believe you should always shoot in colour in digital photography and then change it afterwords. Afterall it is a lot harder to add colour to a B&W photo than to take the colour away from a colour photo.

I am aware of that, its just it seems that the contrast is better if you set the camera to take the picture in black and white.

Choleric · 12-01-2006, 11:40 AM

Yeah but essentially all your B&W mode on the camera is doing, is the same thing you do to it in photoshop, so why not have the abilty to control your contrast and other adjustments.

Michael · 12-01-2006, 12:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Choleric

Yeah but essentially all your B&W mode on the camera is doing, is the same thing you do to it in photoshop, so why not have the abilty to control your contrast and other adjustments.

I am not to sure about the Jeff. I don't think desaturated the picture is the samething the camera does. I don't know...

NevadaJack · 12-01-2006, 12:36 PM

In the Canon when you select B&W you can set the parameters to control Contrast and Sharpness but also you can add Filter Effects such as yellow, orange, red or green. If you plan to use the finished image in B&W then I would think it better to shoot in B&W mode. You can also add toning effects such as Sepia, Blue, Purple and Green.

If you are not sure, then shooting in color and converting in PS to B&W is the best way to go...at least you have the option of color if you want it.

Choleric · 12-01-2006, 12:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael

I am not to sure about the Jeff. I don't think desaturated the picture is the samething the camera does. I don't know...

I am not sure either but, it is a digital camera so I believe it is taking a colour photo and is making it B&W by taking the colour away(desaturating), so I guess imo I would like to have the original in colour and work with it as I see fit.

Michael · 12-01-2006, 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by NevadaJack

In the Canon when you select B&W you can set the parameters to control Contrast and Sharpness but also you can add Filter Effects such as yellow, orange, red or green. If you plan to use the finished image in B&W then I would think it better to shoot in B&W mode. You can also add toning effects such as Sepia, Blue, Purple and Green.

If you are not sure, then shooting in color and converting in PS to B&W is the best way to go...at least you have the option of color if you want it.

That is very interesting Jack. I wonder if I could do the same with my Nikon. I am sure I can.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Choleric

I am not sure either but, it is a digital camera so I believe it is taking a colour photo and is making it B&W by taking the colour away(desaturating), so I guess imo I would like to have the original in colour and work with it as I see fit.

I am sure you are right, I just would think why would the option be there if you could do the same thing in photoshop? you know? I am sure there is a difference even if it is subtle.

NevadaJack · 12-01-2006, 01:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael

That is very interesting Jack. I wonder if I could do the same with my Nikon. I am sure I can.

I am sure you are right, I just would think why would the option be there if you could do the same thing in photoshop? you know? I am sure there is a difference even if it is subtle.

Check the manual Michael...I would expect in your model the B&W Option would be there being a semi-pro camera like the 20D.

11-30-2006, 01:36 PM	#1
Michael Devotee Moderator Emeritus Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Florida Posts: 3,530 Thanks: 239 Thanked 323 Times in 196 Posts	Black & White photography? Does anyone know if there is a difference between the pictures coming from a camera that has the black and white setting on as compared to taking the picture, made in color, and desaturating it in photoshop? Aren't the effects different? Meaning, aren't the black and white photos from the camera nicer?

11-30-2006, 11:59 PM	#2
Choleric Moderator Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Aksarben Posts: 3,201 Thanks: 613 Thanked 1,131 Times in 613 Posts	Re: Black & White photography? You have a lot more control if you convert it to B&W in photoshop, I also believe you should always shoot in colour in digital photography and then change it afterwords. Afterall it is a lot harder to add colour to a B&W photo than to take the colour away from a colour photo.

12-01-2006, 11:40 AM	#4
Choleric Moderator Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Aksarben Posts: 3,201 Thanks: 613 Thanked 1,131 Times in 613 Posts	Re: Black & White photography? Yeah but essentially all your B&W mode on the camera is doing, is the same thing you do to it in photoshop, so why not have the abilty to control your contrast and other adjustments.

12-01-2006, 12:36 PM	#6
NevadaJack Fanatic Join Date: Oct 2005 Location: Las Vegas, NV USA Posts: 1,099 Thanks: 85 Thanked 296 Times in 136 Posts	Re: Black & White photography? In the Canon when you select B&W you can set the parameters to control Contrast and Sharpness but also you can add Filter Effects such as yellow, orange, red or green. If you plan to use the finished image in B&W then I would think it better to shoot in B&W mode. You can also add toning effects such as Sepia, Blue, Purple and Green. If you are not sure, then shooting in color and converting in PS to B&W is the best way to go...at least you have the option of color if you want it.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
The Mercedes SLK 55 AMG Black Series	Alx	SLK-Class	39	08-30-2007 02:11 AM
My Geneva trip 2006	Just_me	Sightings	71	08-19-2007 10:15 AM
Black and White luxury	SDNR	Internal Combustion	2	11-24-2006 05:56 AM
Phantom Black: 25-car limited run from Rolls-Royce	Alx	Phantom Limousine	28	07-13-2006 05:53 PM
Mercedes Unimog U 500 Black Edition by BRABUS	BMW_Dude	The Mercedes-Benz Lounge	3	12-20-2005 06:57 AM