KokkenTor

Results from AutoZeitung test: Audi A4 cab 3.0 TDI Quattro vs BMW 330d cab vs MB CLK 320 CDI cab

1. BMW 330d cab – 3 020 points
2. Audi A4 cab 3.0 TDI Quattro – 2 929 points
3. MB CLK 320 CDI cab – 2 903 points

More details later on (Sunday?)

Just_me

I read this in the store, 330d little faster up to 180km/h and about 4 seconds faster than CLK around a track. Just shows how "old" CLK is getting.

KokkenTor

1. BMW 330d cab – 3 020 points
2. Audi A4 cab 3.0 TDI Quattro – 2 929 points
3. MB CLK 320 CDI cab – 2 903 points

Some Details:

Model ………….......…… A4 3.0 TDI q .. 330d .. CLK 320CDI
Karosserie ….....…………… 558 ………….. 593 …….. 570
Comfort ……….........…….. 704 ………….. 709 …….. 701
Engine/gear ..............… 710 ………….. 724 …….. 718
Driving Dynamics .……... 603 ………..…. 659 ……. 576
Cost/environment ……... 354 ………….. 335 ……… 338
Total …………….........….. 2 929 ………. 3 020 …… 2 903

Weight (kg) ………….….. 1 840 ………. 1 800 ….. 1 780
Consumtion .….……..…… 10,1 ……….…. 9,7 …..…. 9,5
Lap time ……....……….. 1:50,3 ……… 1:46,3 …. 1:50,6
Slalom (km/h)……….…… 56,3 …..….. 58,9 ..…… 55,9
0-100km/h ................ 7,3 ........... 7,3 ......... 7,2
0-180km/h ............... 24,4 ......... 23,1 ....... 23,4
80-120km/h .............. 5,1 ........... 4,6 ......... 4,9
Hp/Nm ................. 233/450 …. 231/500 ... 224/510
Price (€) ............... 44 850 ….…. 49 000 …... 50 099

ree

CLK 320 CDI is faster then I thought... ...and it is still very good looking. I think this would be my choice between these three convertibles.

Just_me

Noway, CLK is so old , E93 is the newest, freshest and best allrounder.

ree

Fortunately, there are a lot of car companies, who offer different types of cars for different types of persons.

Just_me

But what if you had the fortune to testdrive all three here and you found out that the E93 suited you the best. Would you still choose CLK becuase you happen to like the exterior better?

EnI

Nothing spectacular here. Folding hardtop is a huge advantage. I'm sure E93 will be a winner also after A5 cabrio & new CLK cabrio are introduced - under condition of coming with canvas roof.

BMW are very serious here. For the next gen of Z4, Z8 & 6er cabrio folding hardtops are seriously considered. And will make it into production - except in case something really goes wrong (eg. if driving dynamics - especially in M variants - is affected too much).

So only low-end models (Z2 & 1er cabrio) will get canvas, while other models are (planned) to get folding hardtops.

What would that mean for CLK, SLK & SL?

Mr. Mercedes

MB surely wouldn't let BMW get away with being the only Hardtop offering. Next generation CLK HAS to have one.

EnI

Better be so. Otherwise CLK (same case with A5) will be in serious troubles. I've also heard Lexus delayed IS cabrio launch due sending the car back into development - to develop folding hardtop instead of planned canvas one.