Just_me

from m5board.com, no scans or accelerationnumbers presented. Just the conclusion.

This is what Steve Sutcliffe (known for favouring Porsche) said after testing the above three cars:

"A thought occurred as I climbed back into 'my' long term BMW M6 after two days spent driving the 911 Turbo and its rivals. It was this: why does the car world think 80 grand is too much for an M6 when these three cars cost over 100k each yet none of them are an faster in a straight line where it counts, or more civilised on a motorway, or anywhere near as well equipped, or as spacious, or as economical?

It's the difference, largely, in brand expectation. People are prepared to pay more for a Ferrari, Lamborghini or Porsche than they are for a BMW, and that's fair enough. A £15 Casio watch tells the time, as does a £15,000 Rolex Daytona etc...

But there comes a point when you think, hang on, who's right here? And the biggest surprise of all is that, all in all, I think I prefer the M6 to the 911 Turbo, money no object. In the real world it's just as fast (faster after a one-mile drag race, in fact, as we discovered on the runway at London City Airport recently) and for most of the time suits more of my needs, more of the time. In that light, 80 grand almost seems like a bargain. And £65k for an M5 becomes the sale of the century.

Alx

He loves his car, but lets be realistic, the M6 goes for over $105K here in the US, and obviously people are paying a premium too. Nontheless a great car the M6.

Where is the 997TT Vs. Gallardo Vs.F430 write up?

He doesnt even talk about it in that quote, in fact he talks about the M6 which isnt even in the comparo...

Andreas, you feeling okay today?

Just_me

the text comes from a m6owner on m5board.com and he read it in Autocar. he obviosly havent posted all, just the conclusion. And the conclusion is what you read above...and no, the guy from Autocar dont own a M6, its a comparison.

Just_me

you have the orginal thread here and as you can see I didnt left anything out

- ONLY REGISTERED AND ACTIVATED USERS CAN SEE ALL LINKS - CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Im just the messenger...

Alx

Im sorry, im confused, maybe its last nights Grey Goose Vodka throwing me off, but he's comparing an M6 to the cars 997TT,F430,Gallardo. Which actually has nothing to do with the comparison since the M6 isnt even a part of it, and overall the guy doesnt even mention the test and concludes the car that isnt even part of the comparo is the true winner?

Again, im just confused, is that pretty much what you posted?

Just_me

see my post above yours dont shot the messenger...

Alx

Its shoot, Dont shoot the messenger, and im not doing that at all. Just asking for some clarification. Im not quite sure whats going on...

Nevermind J_M. Im too tired to get into it any further, re-reading the post only makes my headache worse.

Just_me

No Alex you shot me yesterday, you arent going to shoot me today. Back to the future Alex...

Alx

Did I ?!?! Sorry man, your like one of the last guys i would want to shoot.

And obviously im not a good aim since your still here .

Ok, than the original poster is mentally challenged, and cant put a story together, go BAN him from the forum or something, it will make me feel better, or better yet, ask him what the hell he is talking about, and after you get a confusing reply ban him!

Alx

You know, in the spirit of this thread, im going to start a similar thread in the sound and vision section regarding a write up comparison of the Zonda, a Fountain Race boat, and a Suzuki Hayabusa motorcycle. I will only post my interpretation of the ending with absolutley no information on the vehicles used in the comparo, in fact, i will discuss how the VW Beetle TDI actually gets the best gas mileage from the entire group.

Im a go work on that right now!!!

Thanks Andreas, you and your witty writing friend are an inspiration too me.

LOL!